Jump to content
  • Staff Pick


  • Welcome to Artists Beware! 

    All posts have been reviewed prior to being allowed in.


    Comments are moderated:  Please review the Commenting Rules.  Comments that don't meet our rules will not be posted.

    If your post is resolved:  Contact one (1) member of staff or leave a comment, and we'll update your post!

    If a beware needs a tag update:  Post a comment!

    To contact a member of staff:  See the Staff page or fill out the Contact Us form.

    Posts are not deleted unless you can prove they are fabricated.  If this is the case contact one (1) admin, and we will help you asap.

  • Artist Caution - ApoChi Studios/Chioro


    Veldazik
    • Who: ApoChi Studios
      Where: https://www.furaffinity.net/user/chioro
      https://twitter.com/ApoChiStudios
      When: 04/06/2019
      What: Commission
      NSFW Content Resolved
    Message added by Eden

    The discord chats were removed as they weren't proof of anything beyond OP talking about the commission publicly. 

    Disclaimer: the screenshots I have are the best I can get from discord chats where I talked with others about the commission months ago. Commissioner blocked me (see attachment 1) immediately after my saying I wasn't content with my commission compared to others they've done, thus I cannot get any other screenshots than those I have here.

     

    --

    Proper:

    Our first contact about the commission was right after they posted they were open for commissions and (of I remember right) in need of help financially. I had talked with them previously, as they made a nice little $10 pinup of my lizard boy (Attachment 2), and I even made them a little art as thanks in return. They seemed nice, so why not help them out and see what they can do for a full piece?

    April 7th, I paid the $140 (attachment 3) for a full shaded piece with a background and showed them all my references for my Y/veltal and U/mbreon characters performing missionary position and its supposed to be romantic. I will note that shaded characters is worth more than background (attachment 4), and the background ended up being the subject in the end piece.

    After the start of our commission, they seemed to go pretty fast! They got me the first sketch within 3 days, which came in the form of just a fully lined "background". (attachment 5) Took me off-guard because that never happens, getting the background (lined) before even seeing a sketch of any sort, especially the subjects. Thought maybe the subjects would go on the couch or floor or something (since I didn't specify where, which was in retrospect may have been my first mistake, and they wouldn't tell me what they were about to do). I figured I would wait it out and see what they do.

    Waited quite a while, a month went by, another month...I was beginning to wonder, so I asked if there was any progress. Each time I asked, they simply answered "no progress". Meanwhile on Twitter I had noticed them saying they were too depressed to work or some such thing, then it turned to them being in art school all of a sudden. And whenever they were in the mood, they'd spit out about 5 pinup commissions at a given time. By the time I even got an update (which I will touch on in a moment), there had to have been about 30 to 40 commissions finished by them. That is not an exaggeration. I confronted them about it and after a few times of trying, they did indeed confirm that they took many MANY commissions at once, and it's been piling up ever since. And yet they are still asking for commissions and taking over a year to finish what I assume to be most of them.

    Moving on, the first update I got since the lined background was on February 11th, 2020 (attachment 6) I voiced my concern that the subjects weren't in the foreground and were instead in the background (attachment 7) while also trying to be nice because they were supposedly my friend, and the fact they'd been going through a lot (allegedly). Their only response was "this is what it looks like zoomed in" (attachment 8 ) which is a big yikes because, not only was it low res if you did zoom in, but it's also the fact it's not the focus, is a big no-no. I voiced my concerns again, and she left me on read. 

    February 13th, another update. They only showed that they had colored and shaded the "background" which I thought looked pretty dang good, all things considered. (attachment 9) But no sign of whether Chio decided to move the characters anywhere else. Figured I would wait and see. 

    Fast forward to APRIL 15TH with no prior WIPs, the characters were lined and flat colored already. I was so done and tired at this point and just wanted it done that I just couldn't bear to say anything. Other than just shade them, because obviously there was nothing I could do at this point. They had already got it set in stone without my permission. (attachment 10) 

    Their reaction to "shading" the characters? (like I had bloody paid for) They darken the room. (attachment 11)

    So I figure, well, if you're going to do that, maybe can shade it nice with some glow effects from the U/mbreon that bounce off the Y/veltal and the walls and all?

    No. All that happens is that they add a glow around the markings. (attachment 12) Nothing spectacular. I paid full price for this. And the BACKGROUND is the FOREGROUND, and the characters aren't even shaded.

    Full piece: (attachment 13)

    Friend asking if full piece is a wip: (attachment 14)

    Proof of talking with my friends about this even early on when I found out it was in the background: (attachment 15)

    Other examples of art released at the same time that is better: (attachment 16)

    I'm sorry, but that is a failure to do what you have to do. Failure to communicate and make sure. Failure to get things done. Failure on the level of taking on way too many commissions and getting none done for an eternity. And then screwing up a full piece, which should be considered having /more/ care and effort put into it than your average pinup.

    Tl;dr 

    -Takes too many commissions, and thus takes over a year to do your art

    -Not good at communication on commissions to make sure its what the commissioner wants

    -Overly sensitive if you say anything negative at all

    IMG_20200428_124344.jpg.09891e00ae55eace6c3e2998dc5f6089.jpg

    1557685849_PhotoMar2342812AM.png.c5ffb0f02bba98c926e35e7751e77405.png

     

    IMG_20200212_134320.jpg.0668622ce3a47e1024492469b138f19a.jpg

    There were no WIPs before this.

    Screenshot_20200212-183010.png.788db546b496fcff10cda15f50e55dad.png

    Screenshot_20200428-114942.png.0674434c39056a3e1c2ad419c268fa76.png

    Screenshot_20200428-114951.png.73142f52c45275c6d76768c99eb7249c.png

    Screenshot_20200212-175508.png.4ac3092eb9b58d033dacbef0529719b8.png

    Screenshot_20200428-141038.png.3b5fdd0b1838adc6f62a3e848bd44ac6.png

    Screenshot_20200416-135412.png.90ae82f33c83d0ec401e5d23078236b9.png

    Screenshot_20200416-135428.png.313ab2ad66917458f196bb47b3329636.png

    IMG_20200416_135438_929.jpg.3238ab468e85d70e2041ff96b1f6fa76.jpg

    999494722_PhotoApr1621213PM_copy_1024x1459.png.6fbdf656e4b277376dfc493f8360fff9.png

     

     

    Screenshot_20200417-132444.png.7716b370d45dd33c3a19f5e5aab38166.png

     




    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

     


    Welcome to Artists Beware! 

    All posts have been reviewed prior to being allowed in.

     


    Comments are moderated:  Please review the Commenting Rules.  Comments that don't meet our rules will not be posted.

    If your post is resolved:  Contact one (1) member of staff or leave a comment, and we'll update your post!

    If you are the bewaree:  Review "I've been posted to Artists Beware, now what?".

    If a beware needs a tag update:  Post a comment!

    To contact a member of staff:  See the Staff page or fill out the Contact Us form.

    Posts are not deleted unless you can prove they are fabricated.  If this is the case contact one (1) admin, and we will help you asap.

     

    I am a Bot. My inbox is not monitored. Beep boop.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Administrator

    This one is odd.  The foreground/ background on this piece is really lovely, but it's so wildly different than what they normally make.  Almost all of the art on their twitter is your standard porn, while this one is more atmospheric. With such a drastic difference they really should have shown you a thumbnail or a sketch before jumping all the way into lines.

    Though I do want to say that this is a submission where I would really like to hear the artist's side.  It seems from their Twitter that some pretty ugly things were said from you that you claim to not have when you submitted.  While your submission didn't tick enough boxes to ultimately reject it, this gives me concern as to how much precisely was lost.

    Should the artist have taken cues from you that you weren't happy with this commission?  Yes.  Should they have provided wips before lining?  Yes.  Should you have stood up and said how unhappy you were instead of waffling around the issue?  Yes.  Should you have gone to a separate chat to complain about the art instead of directly talking to the artist?  Absolutely not.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Not sure how I feel about this one. I see why you'd be disappointed, and I recommend to the artist to sketch out the idea and background before going in with lines to show the client.  

    But your messages vs what you've written here is confusing to me. You don't seem to ever ask for an actual change. And for example, you wrote this in the post: 

    "Their only response was "this is what it looks like zoomed in" (attachment 8 ) which is a big yikes because, not only was it low res if you did zoom in, but it's also the fact it's not the focus, is a big no-no."

    But, of course that's what their response was? Your question asked if it was big enough to zoom in, so they showed you. Your message didn't -actually- ask for it be changed. Your screenshots don't see you mention it being low resolution, so I have to assume you didn't mention it. If none of this was said, and you didn't actually straight up ask "can this be changed to being focused on them", I find it hard for the artist to know that's what you wanted. Maybe they should have poked, but it's quite possible they didn't think anything was wrong, text can be read so differently for each person. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    • Senior Staff

    I do think it's out of line that the artist just.. gave you a lineart background within 3 days with no lead-up sketch that really made it feel like the artist just happened to have a pre-made background they wanted to use on your commission. But that's entirely speculation on my part.

    That aside one thing I've noticed is that you never explicitly state you have a problem or want something changed. Something you really need to do is be explicit in the things you want, you can't just assume the person you're speaking too should have known what you meant, that's not how communication works. There's a lot of ways the artist dropped the ball on this, but I think it would have had a better outcome had you explicitly said
    "I want the image to be the close up shot you have there, I do not want the rest of the foreground in this art piece at all"
    or
    "The characters should be the focus, please give them the individual shading and highlights they should have, I don't want the rest of the image darkened, that doesn't solve the problem"

    Or literally anything to that effect at all. And just clarify on my own end, I don't think any of the result was your fault, this was really weird from the get-go, and it's obvious here that the artist wasn't really listening to any of your concerns or really tried to work with you, but when you're clear and direct in the things you want, it leave little room for excuse on the artist's part.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Mod Note:  Looking for the edit button?  Editing is turned off by default, and staff will issue you an edit pass when we review your post.

×
×
  • Create New...